Last Sunday, U.S. users were surprised to see TikTok, briefly halted due to a federal ban, restored to service. According to a report by The Wall Street Journal, this "revival" came after former President Donald Trump, set to resume office on Monday, announced an executive order allowing TikTok to operate temporarily in the U.S. under the condition that its Chinese parent company, ByteDance, divests 50% of TikTok’s ownership to American investors.
As a global application with over 1 billion users, TikTok's shutdown created confusion, frustration, and anger among its 170 million U.S. users. This conflict underscores a long-standing geopolitical battle waged in the name of "national security." U.S. policymakers view TikTok as a symbol of China's expanding digital influence and have significant concerns about data security. However, ByteDance has repeatedly emphasized that TikTok’s global operations are largely funded by American capital, with data stored in the U.S. and supervised by Oracle.
Trump’s proposal to transfer 50% of TikTok’s U.S. operations to American ownership is a compromise aimed at reducing reliance on Chinese technology while maintaining national security. This move reflects a balance between his "America First" policy and a pragmatic approach to addressing the public’s demand for TikTok.
TikTok's saga not only highlights tensions between China and the U.S. but also reveals the complexities of technological decoupling. The U.S. demand for ByteDance to sell TikTok’s U.S. operations faces significant obstacles due to China’s 2020 Technology Export Control Regulations, which restrict the transfer of TikTok’s core algorithm. This reinforces the strategic importance of technology in national disputes.
Trump’s decision to allow TikTok’s temporary operation appears less about addressing privacy or security concerns and more about managing domestic political and economic risks. A forced shutdown or divestiture could expose American companies to retaliatory measures abroad, while TikTok’s absence could disrupt local advertisers, small businesses, and creators who rely on the platform. Without viable alternatives in the current social media ecosystem, such actions could lead to public backlash and economic losses.
By granting an extension and issuing a “pardon,” Trump has strategically bought time for negotiations while preserving U.S. leverage in future discussions. However, the potential for long-term stability remains uncertain.
Despite its "pardon," TikTok’s long-term survival in the U.S. remains in jeopardy. If ByteDance fails to reach a sustainable agreement with the U.S. government, user trust and retention may erode. The temporary shutdown has already prompted many users to seek alternative platforms.
Compounding these challenges, the Protecting Americans from Foreign Adversaries Act, recently upheld by the U.S. Supreme Court, places any Chinese app with over 1 million active users under scrutiny. This includes TikTok’s alternatives, such as Lemon8 or Xiaohongshu, both of which risk similar bans.
While Trump’s revised demand for 50% American ownership appears to lower the bar, potential conditions—such as lifting restrictions on U.S. social media in China—may prove contentious. Notably, Elon Musk, rumored to have considered acquiring TikTok, voiced opposition to its ban on X but criticized China’s restrictions on U.S. platforms, calling for "fairer trade practices."
In light of these challenges, ByteDance has begun preparing for worst-case scenarios. While platforms like Xiaohongshu briefly benefited from TikTok’s user exodus, ByteDance has reportedly started redirecting "TikTok refugees" to Douyin, its domestic Chinese counterpart. Overseas users have noted that ByteDance now allows limited registration on Douyin without requiring a Chinese phone number.
Trump’s “pardon” for TikTok may provide temporary relief but leaves the platform’s future in the U.S. uncertain. With geopolitical tensions and restrictive legislation looming, TikTok’s continued operation depends on strategic negotiations that balance national security, public demand, and economic considerations. Whether TikTok can overcome these hurdles to secure its place in the U.S. market remains to be seen.
WEIYU GLOBAL specializes in providing comprehensive supply chain management solutions for small and startup enterprises in the world. Our mission is to help you optimize their supplier management processes, saving both time and resources while enhancing project cycle and improving supply chain quality.
